Boram din't break Hwayoung's umbrella?

Picture speaks a thousand words,netizens began to speculate that Boram broke Hwayoung's umbrella during the recording of the 2012 MBC Idol Star Olympics.

However,fans found evidence to prove them wrong.Check out the videos below.

You can clearly see that Hwayoung's Umbrella is already broken when she walked that way while Boram and Qri just followed her there.

So i guess video speaks more words that picture right?